Beware toxins in products, study warns
Manufacturers group denies that people are at risk
Chances are, there’s a product in your house that could make you sick. It could be an air freshener, dryer sheets or your shampoo. Even “green” products might include toxic chemicals that aren’t listed on their labels, say researchers at the University of Washington and Battelle. A study published online yesterday in the journal Environmental Impact Assessment Review says that 25 best-selling cleaning and personal-hygiene products emit an average of 17 chemicals each. Battelle scientists tested vapors emitted by the samples, which included hand sanitizers, deodorants and dish detergents.
The researchers found 133 individual chemicals. Of those, nearly 25 percent are classified as toxic or hazardous under at least one federal law, according to the study. “These are chemicals that can damage the brain, the lungs, the central nervous system and cause cancer,” said Anne Steinemann, a professor of civil and environmental engineering at the University of Washington and the study’s lead author.
“And some of these chemicals have no safe exposure level. This means that not even one molecule is risk-free.” Steinemann wouldn’t say which brands they tested but said about 37 percent of American households use a laundry detergent that was examined. And more than one-third of the products give off at least one chemical that the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency says is a probable carcinogen and is dangerous in even the smallest amounts, Steinemann said. One such chemical is methylene chloride, a solvent the FDA banned from cosmetic and personal-care products in 1989. It turned up in baby shampoo, she said.
Even the 11 products that claim to be “green,” “organic,” “nontoxic” or “natural” on their labels emit toxic chemicals, she said.
Neither the Consumer Product Safety Commission nor the Food and Drug Administration, which regulate these products, requires that companies list all of a product’s ingredients, Steinemann said.
“What’s misleading is they typically list some of the chemicals but not all of the chemicals,” she said. “They usually list the benign-sounding ones.” She said she hopes the industry does a better job of labeling and that people use more simple products to clean their houses, such as vinegar and water. *
Brian Sansoni, a spokesman for the American Cleaning Institute, said the research is a stretch. “There’s an implication that all of these are unsafe, and that’s just not the case,” he said. “These aren’t just casually formulated and thrown onto the shelves.” Sansoni said the products are safe when used properly.
A representative from the Consumer Product Safety Commission said the organization hasn’t seen the study and could not comment.
The FDA said it could not respond to the study, but said manufacturers are responsible for making safe products. (Please read this last comment as “You Are on Your Own”!)
fthomas@dispatch.com
TOM DODGE DISPATCH Battelle scientist Martha McCauley shows how vapors are extracted from household products for chemical analysis.(* I know how sated one can feel with all this, but this deeply affects us all. I do not apologize for my repeated efforts to alert you. On a prior post when I learned that my “Tide” which I used was one of the worst offenders with regard to toxins, I immediately sent for the Soap Nuts @ Green Virgin Products and have used them ever since. They have proved to be wonderful, smell good, get stuff clean and because they are a natural product [growing on trees], not toxic in any way AND they relieved me from the need to have to use Downey as the Soap nuts really do leave the clothes soft and nice.. . .this decision has served me well aside from the peace of mind, I am saving money.
This is a difficult problem to deal with as we are not given all the facts in order to be informed enough to make good decisions. I have not used regular deodorant in years. Brush with baking soda. If we can’t trust the “Green products” – don’t know what we are supposed to do. But I know this – we must KEEP DEMANDING that those put there to protect us (e.g. FDA, etc) MUST be required to start doing their job to do just that. We have to keep up the pressure, we are making progress in just this last year or two. Thanks friends for indulging me. Jan)