SMOKINCHOICES (and other musings)

December 4, 2012

Need fresh faces in Cabinet

Obama should appoint fresh faces


Elisse B. Walter?

Is that really whom President Barack Obama named on Monday to be the new chairwoman of the Securities and Exchange Commission? A woman who has been at the SEC for the past four years? And, to boot, someone practically joined at the hip with her predecessor, Mary Schapiro?

No doubt, Walter is a fine public servant. What she is not, however, is a fresh face with new ideas. And isn’t that half the point of second-term appointments? They give a president a chance to name cabinet or agency directors who can breathe new life into their departments.

Take, for instance, Timothy Geithner, the soon-to-be-departing Treasury secretary. Geithner wasn’t a bad secretary. In no small part because of him, America’s banks are far better capitalized — and safer — than their European counterparts. But you always had the sense that his heart lay more with the bankers he was overseeing than with the homeowners who needed help.

That is why our nominee to replace Geithner is his bete noire, Sheila Bair. As the chairwoman of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., a job she held until July 2011, she fought against bank bailouts while pushing for mortgage modifications. Wouldn’t you like a Treasury secretary who believes that interest on debt should not be tax deductible — whether for large financial institutions or home mortgages? I sure would.

Let’s move next to the State Department, where an exhausted Hillary Clinton is ready to step down. She has been, without question, Obama’s finest appointment. She was also his riskiest. The current favorite for the job, Susan Rice, the U.N. ambassador, is a safe choice, but she doesn’t have the breadth that the job requires. Who does? How about Bill Clinton?

The president’s worst appointment, on the other hand, has been Eric Holder at the Department of Justice. Under him, the department got prosecutorial scalps by going after the small fry while letting big guys off the hook. Holder also has been tone-deaf in dealing with Republicans in Congress. Our nominee is a man with a reputation for cleaning up messes: Ken Feinberg, a lawyer who specializes in victim-compensation programs. A former special counsel to the Senate Judiciary Committee, he knows the territory. A master negotiator, he knows how to bridge divides. And his sense of fair play is what this Justice Department most needs.

Department of Defense? David Petraeus. After disclosing an affair with Paula Broadwell and resigning as CIA chief, Petraeus is doing his stint in purgatory. The Defense Department in Obama’s second term is going to need someone who can cut its budget without hurting its mission — and who can reform the most entrenched bureaucracy in Washington. The military brass will run bureaucratic circles around any defense secretary who doesn’t know their tricks. Petraeus can stand up to them.

The current secretary of energy, Steven Chu, is a scientist. A far better choice is an environmentalist who also understands the importance of making intelligent choices. We know just such a man: Fred Krupp of the Environmental Defense Fund. He has said there are enormous climate benefits to using natural gas — so long as methane leakage can be minimized. At the Energy Department, Krupp would be in a position to help make sure that happens.

  • With rumors that Arne Duncan may step down as secretary of education, we nominate Randi Weingarten to replace him. Risky? You bet. But as president of the American Federation of Teachers, Weingarten has long claimed to support reform, so long as it is done with the nation’s teachers instead of at their expense. Making Weingarten the next education secretary would give her the chance to put her money where her mouth is.
  • Which brings us back to the SEC. In The New York Times’ account of Walter’s promotion, it said that the White House might well offer up a new nominee in the future. We know the right man for the job: Sean Berkowitz. Berkowitz, who, in full disclosure, is a friend, led the Enron task force and prosecuted Enron’s top two executives, Jeffrey Skilling and Kenneth Lay. So he knows how to nail the bad guys, which has been a problem for the current SEC.

Since 2007, he has been the global chairman of litigation for Latham & Watkins, one of the nation’s largest law firms. Oh, and one other thing, Mr. President.

He’s from Chicago.

Joe Nocera writes for The New York Times.

(By golly,  methinks Joe Nocera may be one of the best thinkers around.  I love what he has done here as I have wondered about the shape of a new cabinet.    I disagree about choosing Bill Clinton however.  Bill seems devoted to the life he has carved out for himself – – and it suits him !  There is no question he would be superb doing it as he would at anything he turned his mind to.  He has remained one of my favorite human beings of all time. 

I also suspect that Bill and Hillary actually might want some old-fashioned time together.  Joe, you gotta find someone else, please – – don’t stop there !   Jan)


Leave a Comment »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: